Part 1
Gold King Mine Spill
Evan R. Tweedie
Colorado is a state with a history rooted in mining. The vast extent of historic mining in Colorado is part of what made it a populous state in the first place, as people began settling from the eastern US in the mid 19th century as a part of the Colorado Gold Rush. Gold was first discovered in Colorado in 1859, leading to a great influx of people who slowly started moving westward along the Colorado Mineral Belt, which runs northeast to southwest through Colorado from Boulder to Durango (Colorado Geological Survey). Near the southwest end of this belt lies the San Juan Mountains, a mountain range with a history of widespread volcanism that has led to rich mineral deposits scattered throughout. One area in the San Juan Mountains where mining became particularly profitable is the Silverton Caldera, situated along the Animas River Watershed. After gold and silver were discovered in the 1860s by Charles Baker and his party in what is now known as Baker’s Park, people rushed to the area in search of their share of the wealth (Clark 2021). This led to the creation of numerous mining towns in the area. The only remaining town is Silverton, situated at the confluence between Cement Creek and the Animas River. On Cement Creek, 6 miles north of Silverton lies the historic mining district of Gladstone. Gladstone is home to numerous abandoned hardrock mines, including the infamous Gold King Mine, which was responsible for one of the largest wastewater spills in Colorado history.​
​​​
The Gold King Mill and company housing in Gladstone, Colorado (Photo: Western Mining History)
​ In 2015, the Gold King Mine released an estimated 3 million gallons of toxic wastewater into Cement Creek, creating a bright orange plume that travelled down the Animas River and into the San Juan River reaching as far as Lake Powell (Perkins 2021) over the course of 9 days. These waters contained elevated levels of numerous toxic heavy metals including aluminum, arsenic, cobalt, copper, iron, lead, and manganese among others (Roberts 2021), and the pH dropped significantly to around 3 from its regular pH of 7.5 (Clark 2021). People living along the Animas and San Juan Rivers in the towns of Silverton, Durango, Farmington, and Shiprock were all affected by the spill. The event ended up bringing a significant amount of attention to how we look at acid mine drainage (AMD) remediation and water quality as a whole in Colorado.
​​​
Kayakers on the Animas River on the day of the Gold King Mine spill (Photo: Jerry McBride, The Durango Herald)
​ To better understand how the Gold King Mine spill happened, we must look at the work that was being done in the area prior to the spill. After large-scale mining in the Silverton area closed in 1991, the State of Colorado’s Water Quality Control Division (CWQCD) began a new program to establish new standards for water quality in the upper Animas River watershed. This program involved the installation of hydraulic bulkheads to slow seepage from mine entrances, as well as settling ponds and treatment plants to raise the pH of the water with the addition of calcium carbonate or lime (Clark 2021). Despite these new efforts, the Gold King Mine was not included in this program since other areas received priority. As a result, the water quality of Cement Creek and the waters directly below it began to worsen over the years that followed. Bulkheads were installed on some entrances, but didn’t do much in slowing the slow discharge of metal-laden water from the Gold King Mine. “By 2006, peak discharges from GKM had risen to over 300gpm. Three years later, the GKM was found to be releasing nearly 200,000 pounds of metals into the watershed each year” (Clark 2021). In 2010, significant declines in trout populations were recorded in the area, which got the attention of the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), prompting them to consider Superfund designation for the area. At one point, the Sunnyside Gold Corporation (the owner of the land at the time) made an offer of $10 million to fund the construction of a water treatment facility on Cement Creek, in exchange for being exempt of potential liabilities for the restoration of the area going forward. Nothing ever came of this offer until the spill in 2015. In 2014, the Colorado Division of Reclamation, Mining, and Safety (CDRMS) requested of the EPA for the reopening and stabilization of the Gold King Mine’s level 7 adit, which had previously collapsed. After some surface-level work in the area in 2014, a crew consisting of EPA contractors and one CDRMS official returned to the site in 2025 to continue excavation on the level 7 adit. As the crew was excavating the area on August 5, 2015, an EPA contractor miscalculated the depth and pressure of the water behind a bulkhead, creating a breach in the mine entrance. The team quickly stopped what they were doing, but it was already too late. “Within minutes, a portion of bedrock fell away from the mine’s opening and a greater volume shot upward 1.5-2 feet; the breached opening later measured 10 feet in width and 15 feet high” (Clark 2021). It wasn’t long before the water released reached its way into Cement Creek and the Animas River, creating the event we now refer to as the Gold King Mine spill.​
Works Cited
Clark, Brad T. Gold Metal Waters, edited by Brad T. Clark and Pete McCormick, University Press of Colorado, 2021.
“Introduction: From Gold Medal to Gold Metal Waters.” pp. 3-28.
“A Tale of Two Places: The Upper and Lower Animas River Watersheds on Southwest Colorado.” pp. 29-56.​
​
“Historic Mining Districts” Colorado Geological Survey,
https://coloradogeologicalsurvey.org/minerals/historic-mining-districts/#:~:text=This%20r egion%20has%20produced%20much,large%20communities%20like%20historic%20Leadville.
​
Perkins, Luke. “Gold King Mine Spill.” Colorado Encyclopedia,
https://coloradoencyclopedia.org/article/gold-king-mine-spill.
​
Roberts, Scott W. “The Gold King Mine Release: Impacts on Water Quality and Aquatic Life.”
Gold Metal Waters, edited by Brad T. Clark and Pete McCormick, University Press of Colorado, 2021, pp. 57-70.
​
“Roles of EPA and Other Responders After the 2015 Gold King Mine Release.” EPA, updated
2023, https://www.epa.gov/goldkingmine/roles-epa-and-other-responders-after-2015-gold- king-mine-release.​​